Why Top Students Still Struggle with SAT Reading & Writing
Busting SAT Myths, Part 2 of 5
Welcome back to my 5-part series on busting common SAT myths—beliefs that, deep down, most students and parents sense aren’t quite right, but that are tempting to embrace anyway, especially when test day is looming.
In Part 1, I explored why tips and tricks fall short when it comes to SAT prep. But this week’s myth might be the most pervasive of all: Academic success is the best SAT prep.
The reasoning seems sound: The SAT is designed to be a standardized measure of academic ability—less subject to grade inflation and regional variation than a GPA. So if your child excels at a rigorous school, surely that will translate to a strong SAT score. Just do on the test what you do in school, and you’ll be fine.
And yet. By far the most common remark I hear from parents inquiring about tutoring is some version of: “I don’t get it—my child goes to a great school and excels in her classes. But her SAT Reading & Writing score doesn’t measure up. How is this possible?”
Here’s how.
The SAT tests narrow subsets of skills—on its own terms.
The College Board would likely tell you the SAT measures general academic ability—and in a sense, it does. But it does so through sampling: testing narrow, carefully selected subsets of skills and knowledge that are meant to stand in for the whole.
Whether or not that sampling is scientifically valid, the ramifications for your child are the same: only certain skills and knowledge actually show up on the test, and those specific items may or may not be emphasized at your child’s school. Not all grammar rules are tested, for instance—only certain ones, with particular parameters that aren’t necessarily universal.
Case in point: Many bright, high-achieving students come to me having been taught that commas go where there are “natural pauses” in a sentence. In the real world, that’s not necessarily a bad rule of thumb. But I can tell you from experience—if you take that approach on the SAT, you will be disappointed.
And even when the tested skills are taught at school, there’s the question of timing. If your child learned about a particular logical fallacy a year ago, it won’t be front of mind on test day.
The SAT asks questions in unfamiliar, idiosyncratic ways.
Beyond content, there’s format. The SAT tests skills and knowledge in ways that are neither intuitive nor familiar to most students—even those with perfect GPAs.
Consider how often SAT Reading questions include the word “logically,” as in: Which choice most logically completes the text? That word is doing a lot of work. But most students mentally translate the question as “Which answer makes the most sense?”—or, even more generically, “Which answer is correct?” The analytical precision the test demands doesn’t register.
And even for students who do notice that “logically” keeps appearing, the question remains: Okay—how? How exactly is the test taker to analyze the passage and identify the one answer the College Board will accept as logically sound, all in under a minute?
High school coursework, rigorous as it may be, simply doesn’t prepare students for this highly specific —and frankly artificial— scenario. The SAT operates by its own internal logic, imposing unstated parameters and constraints that are invisible to the untrained eye. It’s not that students lack ability—it’s that they’re playing a game whose rules haven’t been fully explained to them.
Academic Achievement Versus SAT Success
Academic achievement matters. It’s a necessary foundation for SAT success. But it is not sufficient. To avoid unpleasant surprises on score release day, don’t fall for the myth that school performance alone will carry the day.
The good news? The unique skills and knowledge for SAT success can be learned. That’s exactly what my SAT Reading & Writing Score Accelerator programed is designed to do—bridge the gap between academic ability and SAT performance through proprietary strategic frameworks, expert instruction, and deliberate practice. The course begins on January 6th, just in time for the March 14th SAT.
Learn more about my SAT Reading & Writing Score Accelerator Course here.
Until next time,
~ Dave
Note: This post was originally published on the Walker Prep blog, where you can find more SAT Reading & Writing resources.
Reminder:
My friend Dave Peterson—aka Dave the Scholarship Coach—is running a special promotion this Winter Break through his daily newsletter, Your Daily Scholarship.
Each day features exclusive 24-hour deals on Scholarship GPS services and offers from his trusted partners, including one from yours truly. (I can’t say exactly what yet—you’ll have to subscribe to Dave’s newsletter to find out.)
These are among the best deals Dave offers all year, and each one lasts only 24 hours. If you’re not already subscribed, now’s the time: click here to subscribe to Your Daily Scholarship.